Malefactour wrote:
Vigil got a lot of interweb hate for the 2 faction blurb on their website. I hope that they are reconsidering the faction system in the game and at least talking with Games Workshop about changing things up. While GW's huge campaigns for tabletop matches have tended toward Order vs. Chaos, they have to have some idea about how poorly received these 2 faction systems are among MMO fans, specifically, pvp'ers. It's my hope that instead of black and white, GW and Vigil will embrace a shades of grey approach, based on specific zones as to what racial factions can wage war or ally with one another.
I was thinking of something similar to a shades of grey approach.
Let's say we have an Ork guild full of raging fanatical dirty-mouthed PvPing reprobates.
A herd of Chaos come to our leader and tell us some shinies are over yonder, along with a damn good fight. Now, this would be a tentative alliance. Tab targeting (assuming it exists), area of effect, etc wouldn't effect Chaos, but if we were to target one we could blow him up on a whim. So Chaos and our guild of frothing crazies team up and snag the shinies and kill the humies, etc.
And then we backstab Chaos and add their heads to our pointy sticks.
All factions would be in the same boat: People aren't hostile to begin with as long as they've teamed up in the fluff. The Imperium of Man could even see Space Marines killing Guard, etc. If they guilded up (perhaps), they'd be permanently allied.
When people see a given faction playing the largest role in a battle, they'll naturally team up against that faction until it's even enough. With two factions total, there is no way to do this and it becomes a huge balance issue.
I feel like two factions would just be an incredible disappointment, because it is extremely clear that they are going against the fluff to make a decision they hope will cater to WoW players, but that's a huge glaring error as I see it. Not only is a two-faction system worse for PvP, it just makes the game that much closer to the "generic MMO" people want them to move away from.